Village Pizza 13550 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY11952 Located on the south side of Main Road in the heart of Mattituck, Village Pizza specializes in brick oven pizza. Village…More Pizza has been in business for more than 20 years, and has been under new ownership since 2005.
Sicilian Pizza & Pasta 55 Route 48, Mattituck, NY11952 This simple, clean pizzeria is family friendly. Known for its Sicilian style pizza, it serves fresh pasta and subs.…More Located in the Route 48 Plaza, the parking lot can be accessed from both Route 48 and Cox Neck Rd. The restaurant seats about 30 people, so large groups should call ahead.
Michelangelo's Pizzeria 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY11952 Michelangelo's Pizzeria features fine, casual and family friendly Italian dining. Known for its "Grandma's…More Style" pizza, Michelangelo's offers several other varieties of specialty pizzas. Other popular items include pasta, subs, soups and salads. Located in the Waldbaum's Plaza on Main Road in Mattituck, this restaurant provides a large, formal dining room at the rear of the building.
Cheesy Charlie's Pizzeria 46455 County Road 48, Southold, NY11971 Cheesy Charlie's Pizzeria features gourmet, specialty pizzas. Pasta, soups, subs, sandwiches, and crab cakes are also on…More the menu. Delivery is available.
That Little Italian Place 110 Front St, Greenport, NY11944 That Little Italian Place is an Italian restaurant that serves personal pizzas, pastas, eggplant parmesan and other…More Italian dishes. The restaurant also has a full bar. The cozy atmosphere is family friendly, and al fresco dining is an added perk.
Emilio's of Greenport 400 Main St, Greenport, NY11944 Emilio's of Greenport offers an extensive menu of gourmet pizzas, hot and cold sandwiches, calzones, and…More homemade Italian dishes including lasagna, manicotti and rigatoni.This family-run restaurant also features a cafe that offers pastries and cappuccino. Patrons can choose to eat in the indoor dining room or outside on the patio overlooking Main Street. Takeout is available.