Our Lady of Good Counsel Church 14300 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY11952 Our Lady of Good Counsel Church is a Roman Catholic Church located on Main Road (Rt. 25) in Mattituck, just west of…More Mattituck High School. The Pastor is Fr. Joseph W. Staudt. According to their website, the mission of Our Lady of Good Counsel Church is to, "strive to be a faith community of one heart and mind." Visit the site for more information on services.