Cornucopia Gift Shop 27 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY11965 This gift shop, open since 1980, is packed with gifts of all types, from mugs and t-shirts to gift cards and jewelry.…More Many of these items are Shelter Island-themed, like the top-selling packets of party napkins printed with a map of the island.
Verbena 123 Main St, Greenport, NY11944 Verbena has been offering its unique inventory of gifts since 1999. If you are looking for a gift for a wedding or…More newborn, Verbena offers good quality merchandise at reasonable prices. Located on the southern end of Main Street, Verbena also offers gift certificates and evening hours in the summer.
Ivy League Flowers & Gifts is family-owned and operated. It offers only the finest floral arrangements and…More gifts, backed by service that is friendly and prompt. The store serves the following areas: Southold, Aquebogue, Cutchogue, East Marion, Greenport, Jamesport, Laurel, Mattituck, Nassau Point, New Suffolk, Orient, Peconic and Shelter Island.
Bauer's Love Lane Shoppe 100 Love Ln, Mattituck, NY11952 Bauer's offers a variety of gifts and home decor, including baby items, footwear, pocketbooks, wall hangings,…More soaps, lotions, candles, jewelry, stationery, signs, vintage items and more. The shop also has a collection of Christmas gift items.
Mint 260 Love Ln, Mattituck, NY11952 Mint carries a collection of up-to-the-minute trends, including dresses, tops, premium denim, jewelry (some handcrafted…More by local jewelers) and an assortment of accessories and gifts.
Barth's Pharmacy 195 Love Ln, Mattituck, NY11952 Part of a chain of trustworthy East End pharmacies, Barth's offers a wide array of health products, snacks and…More quirky gifts in addition to traditional pharmacy services.
Gifts Unlimited 11160 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY11952 Gifts Unlimited was opened in 2005 by Sunny and Sidney, who were the proprietors of Sweets Unlimited of…More Riverhead for 20 years. This store showcases their self-created collection of fine jewelry, made of precious stones, metals, crystals and beach glass. Special ordering is available. Customers will also find hair accessories, plushies, Webkins, assorted chocolates, candies and more.