East End Mixed on Obama Move to Stop Deporting Illegal Immigrants

Residents, advocates surprised by the hot-button announcement.

News that the Obama administration will stop deporting thousands of young undocumented immigrants – and allow for them to get work visas – sparked a mixed reaction on the East End,often boils over.

Southampton resident Elaine Kahl, founder of the Suffolk County Coalition for Legal Immigration/No Amnesty and Citizens Forum, said scores of people are furious over the news.

"Obama’s proposal is nothing but a political football -- he’s trying to get votes," she said. "It’s a tragedy for every taxpaying American citizen. We are outraged."

Meanwhile. U.S. Rep Tim Bishop, immigration, called the move "a positive development for fairness in our immigration policy.”

On Friday, President Obama outlined new criteria that would allow an illegal immigrant to stay in the United States – they must have come to the country when they were younger than 16, lived in the United States for at least five years, be currently enrolled in school, a high school graduate, or a member of the military, have no criminal record and pose no threat to national security, and be under 30 years old.

"It is an amazing step," said Isabel Sepulveda, founder of Organizacion Latino Americana of Eastern Long Island. "There are so many young people that are going to be blessed by this. It's a positive step because these young people have so much to give to this country. Over the years, I have seen young people dropping out of school because they are discouraged, because they don't see a light in their future. This changes everything." 

Southampton Village Mayor Mark Epley has long been faced with escalating tensions over a proposed hiring site for day laborers on n the village as response to the scores of day laborers seeking work outside 7-Eleven.

Epley said on Friday he'd like to see broader reform on the federal level. "Unfortunately, I think its going to be politicized this year," Epley said. "This piece really should be brought into overall immigration reform. That's one of the things we've just failed our country on. We've got to get everybody on the same page."

Sister Margaret Smyth of the North Fork Spanish Apostolate said Obama’s efforts are wonderful but expects there are some who will find little relief in the administration's policy shift. "One of the young fellows in my church is a wonderful young man who came here at 15, but went directly to work," she said. "He has never been to school; he can’t apply."

There are many questions that still need to be answered, Smyth said, including whether young people might be able to enroll quickly in school and qualify, or if some teens who have been here less than five years can apply in the future.

Smyth said she and a number of immigrants she serves gathered around the television at her Riverhead office on Friday to watch Obama’s press conference. "It’s wonderful news," she said. "You can’t punish the kids that came here that young."

Sylvia Baruch, founder of the Hampton Bays based applauded Obama’s move. "It’s a great beginning," she said. "It’s not an end – it’s not even a middle – but’s it’s a great beginning to recognize that there are young people who have the capacity to, or have already made, enormous contributions to this country."

Mike Anthony, another NISI member, said the move was great.

"This action by President Obama is appropriate and necessary. It does neither the country of origin, nor the USA, any good to keep these young people's' lives in legal limbo. Everyone has a stake in these young people's' lives. Our taxes helped educate them; we have invested in their lives."

But others questioned Obama's decision. Amagansett resident Lynda Edwards said Obama has "overstepped his authority. This is a legislative, not an executive act. This is not something that he should be doing. He's doing so many things by executive order -- by bypassing Congress, which is wrong. I'm waiting for Congress to stand up and act like they have a backbone."

At his televised press conference, Obama was heckled by members of the crowd asking what would be done about the thousands of unemployed Americans in the country legally.

"We have drawn strength in being a nation of immigrants," Obama said. “There’s no reason we can’t come together and get this done. These kids deserve to plan their lives in more than two-year increments.”

Obama also said comprehensive immigration reform must be addressed to make sure the agricultural industries and science fields have a stable work force.

Joe Gergela, executive director of the Long Island Farm Bureau, said Obama's effort was positive. "It gives us, at least, the hope that perhaps it will lead to future policy for a guest worker visa program for agriculture."

“Not only is it the right thing to do for the economy, it’s the right thing to do, period,” Obama said.

But Kahl disagreed, especially given the timing ahead of the next election.

"I think President Obama has made a big political mistake."

Let Patch save you time. Get great local stories like this delivered right to your inbox or smartphone everyday with our free newsletter. Simple, fast sign-up here.

Jaguar-Guy June 18, 2012 at 11:07 AM
Man, I am sitting here wondering the ultimate question - why would anyone WANT to be President anyway ?? You can never make enough people happy, no matter what you try to do. Tim Bishop, thank you for your service, and Randy - why are you running again ?? Political office seems to be one of the more thankless jobs. Constant attacks and constant repair of your reputation. I have a renewed respect for them all. Not a job I want.
Rick Hoyt June 18, 2012 at 12:44 PM
Jaguar, You Are Spot On About Almost Everything, But "Respect" Politicans ? - Sorry, Most Are In The System For Themselves, I Do Think On The Local Level It Can be Altruistic.But Generally On The National Scale - They Are In For $ Or Want To be Noticed-Fame, Or On Some Freaking Power Trip, Because they Got Picked On In Kindergarten And Want Revenge, A Little Sarcastic Humor...
Jaguar-Guy June 18, 2012 at 01:11 PM
Thanks, and yes, let me write that I respect their stomach for the muck-n-mire.
Jaguar-Guy June 18, 2012 at 01:13 PM
100% correct Bill - Thank you.
Rick Hoyt June 18, 2012 at 01:46 PM
Hello Jaguar, I Understand Your Thinking, But Politicians/Psychopaths Don't Empathize, It's All About Their Narcissism.Smooth Talking Reptilians / Replicants, Of Coarse Generalizing Here, Not a Romney Fan Either Believe, These Are Our Choices ? Hopefully Ron Paul Will Run As An Independant ? - The Necons Have Already Neutered Him, Has Been All Crickets With The MSM.Best-Rick


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »